Start with a goal your teenager chose. Look for one thing he is doing differently outside the sessions, ask what he finds useful, and compare that with where he started. A short review with him and, where appropriate, his mentor can help you decide what to keep, what to adjust and when to reconsider the fit.
Agree what a small change would look like
Ask your son what he wants to be able to do. If he says “speak up more”, ask where that would matter to him. In a sports club, it might mean asking the coach a question when he needs help. At home, it might mean asking for a say in planning his weekend. Choose one situation where he would welcome support and agree what he is happy for you to notice. The NHS recommends asking open questions and helping teenagers think things through for themselves. NHS guidance on talking to your teenager
Agree when to check in. You could ask, “When this comes up again, what would tell you it’s getting a bit easier?” Let him describe the starting point in his own words.
Keep three things separate at the check-in
- What he tried. Did he do the action he picked? If he didn’t, ask what got in the way.
- What changed. Did he do it more often, with less prompting, or in a situation he used to avoid? Record a specific example.
- What he thought. Which part of the support did he find useful? What would he like to do differently next time?
Attending a session tells you he took part. The other questions help you understand what he is using outside it. His view matters even when your observations differ. MENTOR’s programme guidance includes regular check-ins with young people and caregivers, using open questions. MENTOR guidance on monitoring and supporting mentoring relationships
What progress might look like in practice
This is a hypothetical example. A boy wants to ask for help at his sports club when he gets stuck. He usually waits until he gets home to tell a parent what happened. This week he asks the coach one question after training. At the review, he says rehearsing an opening line helped and asks to try asking during a session next time.
You have a specific action, his account of what helped and a next step he wants to try. Keep the explanation open. More familiarity with the coach or a different session could have played a part too. At the next check-in, ask whether he had another opportunity and what he did with it.
What if the same difficulty keeps coming up?
Start by checking whether the goal still matters to him and whether he’s had a realistic chance to try it. If he wants to keep it, ask what support would make the next step more workable. Agree one adjustment and a time to review it. If he consistently finds the sessions unhelpful or wants to stop, make space for that conversation and ask the provider to discuss the options with him and you.
For a parent review, bring one observation, one question from your son and one decision you want to make. Ask the provider what progress information you can expect and how concerns can be raised. PM&D’s Foundation describes planned midpoint and end reviews and the information parents can expect to receive. PM&D’s parent visibility questions
If you’re still comparing providers, start with the questions to ask before choosing a mentor.